Attorney general says 'doubt' Omar Sheikh to be freed as Pakistan appeals Pearl verdict

Ahmed Omar Saeed Sheikh appears at the court in Karachi, Pakistan, on March 29, 2002. (AP/File)
Short Url
Updated 29 January 2021
Follow

Attorney general says 'doubt' Omar Sheikh to be freed as Pakistan appeals Pearl verdict

  • Sindh province has filed review petition against Supreme Court order to release all four men charged with American journalist Daniel Pearl’s 2002 abduction and murder
  • To a question about whether it was possible that Sheikh could be released, attorney general Khalid Javed Khan told Arab News Pakistan: “I doubt it”

ISLAMABAD/KARACHI: The government of Pakistan’s Sindh province has filed a review petition against a “split judgement” by the Supreme Court to order the release of all four men, including British-born Ahmad Saeed Omar Sheikh, originally arrested and charged with American journalist Daniel Pearl’s 2002 abduction and murder, the Sindh prosecutor general said on Friday, with the attorney general saying he doubted Sheikh would be set free. 

Sheikh was sentenced to death and three other suspects to life in prison in 2002 for their roles in the plot to kill Pearl, a 38-year-old Wall Street Journal journalist. Sheikh was convicted of helping lure Pearl to a meeting in Pakistan’s southern port city of Karachi in 2002, during which he was kidnapped. 

Last April, however, a lower court acquitted all four men in a shocking turn in the 18-year-old case.

The acquittal was appealed separately in the Supreme Court by Pearl’s family and the Sindh government. Both appeals were rejected on Thursday by a three-judge bench, headed by Justice Mushir Alam, that also ordered Sheikh be released. The decision was two-to-one. 

Sindh prosecutor general Syed Faiz Shah confirmed to Arab News that a review petition against Thursday's judgement had been filed by the provincial government.

“Sindh will be filing against the split two-one judgement of the supreme court in the Daniel Pearl case,” Murtaza Wahab, a Sindh government spokesperson and advisor on law told Arab News. “We will argue against the split decision.”

“The prosecutor general Sindh has filed the review against the apex court’s verdict and it’s up to the court now to decide on it,” the office of the attorney general for Pakistan told Arab News on Friday. 

To a question about whether it was possible that Sheikh could be released, attorney general Khalid Javed Khan said: “I doubt it.” 

Late on Thursday, the Pakistan government, through the office of the attorney general, had said it fully supported the Sindh government with regards the Pearl case and would file at the earliest a “petition seeking review and recall of the order of acquittal passed by the Supreme Court.” 

US Secretary of State Antony Blinken has said the United States recognized past Pakistani actions to hold Sheikh accountable and appreciated that he currently remained detained under Pakistani law. 

“We take note of the Attorney General’s statement that he intends to seek review and recall of the decision,” Blinken said in a statement. “We are also prepared to prosecute Sheikh in the United States for his horrific crimes against an American citizen.” 

But Sheikh’s lawyer told Arab News there was no chance his client could be extradited to the US or tried there. 

“Under what provision they [US] want him [Sheikh] extradited, for what offense and on what charge,” said Mahmood A. Sheikh, who is not related to his client. “This is not a trial which was done behind the back of the US government. The US participated in this trial by sending a contingent of FBI officers to Pakistan who along with the police investigated the case. They appeared as witnesses in the trial court.” 

He also said there could be no “double jeopardy” under Pakistani law.

“If a person has been acquitted or convicted after a due trial in Pakistan, he cannot be charged and tried for that offense again,” the lawyer said. “Similar provision is available in the US constitution ... So the United States government may have a desire and wish to lay its hands on this person, but this won’t happen.”

Ashtar Ausaf Ali, a senior Supreme Court lawyer and former Attorney-General for Pakistan, said since one judge on the three-member bench had given a dissenting view, “there are chances of a legal remedy" for the petitioners.


Three cars of a passenger train derail in Pakistan, injuring 27 people

Updated 7 sec ago
Follow

Three cars of a passenger train derail in Pakistan, injuring 27 people

  • Emergency responders, paramedics were quickly dispatched to site, all injured were listed in stable condition
  • An investigation has been launched to determine the cause of the accident, railways spokesperson Babar Raza says

LAHORE: Three cars of a passenger train derailed near Lahore in eastern Pakistan on Friday, injuring at least 27 people, including women and children, officials said.

The Islamabad Express was en route to Lahore when three of its cars went off the tracks in the town of Kala Shah Kaku, railways spokesperson Babar Raza told reporters.

He said emergency responders and paramedics were quickly dispatched to the site, and all the injured were listed in stable condition.

Raza did not provide further details but said an investigation has been launched to determine the cause of the accident.

Train accidents are relatively common in Pakistan, where the railway system has suffered from decades of underinvestment, outdated tracks, and aging signal infrastructure.

In 2023, at least 30 people were killed when a passenger train derailed in the southern city of Nawabshah in Sindh province.


Pakistan says decision to roll back digital tax on foreign retailers to boost e-commerce sector

Updated 57 min 30 sec ago
Follow

Pakistan says decision to roll back digital tax on foreign retailers to boost e-commerce sector

  • Government introduced a five percent levy on foreign digital platforms in the federal budget
  • Local retailers link the tax reversal to US trade deal, say the decision favors global tech giants

KARACHI: A senior Pakistani finance official said on Friday the government had decided to roll back a recently imposed digital tax on foreign retailers in an effort to promote e-commerce in the country.

The Federal Board of Revenue (FBR), the government’s tax collection body, reversed this week a set of measures introduced in the federal budget that were aimed at regulating cross-border online purchases and affected international firms like China’s Temu, Shein and AliExpress.

These included a five percent fixed tax on digital platforms and a sharp reduction in the duty-free threshold for imported parcels, slashing it from Rs5,000 ($18) to Rs500 ($1.8).

“The government plans to continue expanding the e-commerce sector by keeping the market open to international players,” Finance Adviser Khurram Schehzad told Arab News.

The move has sparked backlash from local retailers, who argue that the policy puts them at a disadvantage.

“The removal of the five percent levy on foreign goods is likely to negatively affect domestic sellers, including small businesses and established retailers,” Asfandyar Farrukh, Chairman of the Chainstore Association of Pakistan (CAP), said.

According to CAP, foreign platforms, primarily those belonging to China, are sending as many as 30,000 parcels daily to Pakistani consumers, up from just 1,000 two years ago. Internal courier company data shared by CAP shows this as a nearly 2,900 percent surge in parcel volumes.

Farrukh also questioned the timing and motivation behind the policy reversal, linking it to Pakistan’s recent trade negotiations with the United States.

“The government’s decision to withdraw the digital proceeds levy appears to have been heavily influenced by the US trade deal,” he said, pointing out that American tech giants such as Google and Meta were also affected by the tax and are now exempt.

“The five percent levy should have been maintained on foreign goods, even if removed for services, where it arguably didn’t apply.”

Still, Farrukh acknowledged parallel budgetary measures, such as the reduction in the duty-free threshold and stricter customs enforcement, may temper some of the impact.

“Authorities are now more vigilant in ensuring that foreign e-commerce goods aren’t under-invoiced to evade taxes at import,” he added.

Economist Shankar Talreja echoed some of these concerns.

“This tax withdrawal encourages the use of imported products at the cost of domestic manufacturing,” he said. “It promotes a trading culture rather than production.”

Talreja, who heads research at Karachi-based Topline Securities, added the domestic industry is losing competitiveness as local products are taxed through sales and income levies, while foreign goods bypass the same regulatory burden.

He agreed with the CAP chairman about the circumstances of the tax withdrawal.

“The government, according to reports, reversed the tax under pressure from trade talks with the US,” he said.

Pakistan’s retail sector includes about five million shops generating an estimated Rs20 trillion ($71 billion) annually, but only 10 percent of this comes from the tax-compliant formal sector that CAP represents.

Temu did not respond to Arab News’s request for comment. Shein and AliExpress could not immediately be reached.


Pakistan PM orders damage review in GB, AJK as monsoon deaths reach 299

Updated 01 August 2025
Follow

Pakistan PM orders damage review in GB, AJK as monsoon deaths reach 299

  • Torrential downpours in both regions triggered landslides, left hundreds of tourists stranded
  • Authorities warned of glacial lake outburst floods as water levels surged in glacier-fed areas

ISLAMABAD: Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif on Friday directed authorities to carry out immediate assessments of the loss of life and property caused by recent monsoon rains in Gilgit-Baltistan (GB) and Azad Jammu & Kashmir (AJK) regions that have been hit hard by flash floods and landslides.

Sharif issued the instructions while chairing a meeting amid rising concerns over the severity of the monsoon season that started in the country on June 26.

While casualties in GB and AJK have so far been reported to be comparatively lower than in Punjab or Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, torrential downpours triggered devastating landslides and stranded hundreds of tourists.

Authorities also issued glacial lake outburst flood (GLOF) warnings as water levels rose rapidly in glacier-fed catchments.

“The federal government stands shoulder to shoulder with the people, administration and governments of AJK and Gilgit-Baltistan,” the prime minister was quoted as saying by his office said in a statement.

“All relevant federal agencies should coordinate with local authorities to estimate the damages incurred in the affected areas,” he added.

Sharif said he will also visit Gilgit-Baltistan soon and roll out a relief package.

Pakistan’s National Disaster Management Authority (NDMA) has reported 299 fatalities in its latest situation report on August 1, with maximum casualties in Punjab (162) and Khyber Pakhtunkhwa (69).

The NDMA data show 10 fatalities in GB and two in AJK, though several tourists were said to be missing in these area since the beginning of the monsoon season.


Pakistan’s annual inflation accelerates to 4.1% in July

Updated 01 August 2025
Follow

Pakistan’s annual inflation accelerates to 4.1% in July

  • The central bank left the key interest rate unchanged at 11% this week
  • The SBP said the policy rate would keep inflation between 5%-7% range

ISLAMABAD: Pakistan’s consumer inflation accelerated to 4.1% year-on-year in July, up from 3.2% in June, driven by rising prices for food items, fuels and medicines, the statistics bureau said on Friday.

July’s consumer price inflation month-on-month was 2.9%, the bureau said.

The higher inflation reading follows the State Bank of Pakistan’s assessment of a deteriorating inflation outlook, leading it to leave the key interest rate unchanged at 11%.

The bank’s monetary policy committee said on Wednesday that energy prices, particularly for gas, had risen more than expected, and it considered the real policy rate should be adequately positive to keep inflation in the 5%-7% target range.

Pakistan is pushing through a series of economic reforms under a $7 billion International Monetary Fund program, including a contractionary government budget passed in June that slashes spending to curb the fiscal deficit.


Pakistani opposition alliance says government trying to ‘eliminate’ rivals, calls for joint strategy

Updated 01 August 2025
Follow

Pakistani opposition alliance says government trying to ‘eliminate’ rivals, calls for joint strategy

  • A two-day multiparty conference condemns convictions of opposition leaders in cases of May 9 rioting
  • Minister Ata Tarar says May 9 trials were fair, accuses the opposition of lacking facts and arguments

ISLAMABAD: A coalition of prominent Pakistani opposition leaders on Friday called for a unified political strategy to address what they described as a systematic effort to eliminate dissent, condemning recent convictions related to the May 9, 2023, riots and rejecting the legitimacy of the 2024 general elections.

The two-day multiparty conference was convened by the Tehreek-e-Tahafuz-e-Ayeen-e-Pakistan (TTAP) — or Movement for the Protection of Pakistan’s Constitution — a newly formed alliance of politicians, lawyers and civil society leaders advocating for constitutional supremacy and civilian rule.

Established earlier this year, TTAP is chaired by veteran Pashtun leader Mahmood Khan Achakzai and held its gathering in Islamabad at the residence of former senator Mustafa Nawaz Khokhar, who said the capital administration had attempted to block the event by sealing off its original venue.

“There is a clear attempt to eliminate the opposition in this country,” Khokhar said toward the end of the gathering, adding: “All parties at the conference unanimously agreed that a comprehensive and joint strategy is urgently needed to steer the country out of this crisis.”

The conference condemned the convictions handed down to the leaders and supporters of the country’s jailed former Prime Minister Imran Khan’s Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) party over their alleged role in the May 9 unrest.

The protests, triggered by Khan’s brief detention by paramilitary rangers on corruption charges, turned violent, with attacks on military installations across the country. An anti-terrorism court in Pakistan convicted the leaders of the opposition in the National Assembly and Senate on charges of being involved in the unrest, though the PTI has frequently described such cases and convictions as politically motivated.

The government, however, said all those who were sentenced were given fair trials within the legal and constitutional framework.

“Fair trials were conducted in the May 9 cases in accordance with the law,” Information Minister Ata Tarar asserted in a televised statement following the opposition alliance’s news conference. “The proceedings lasted two full years, during which the prosecution presented its arguments and evidence.”

The multiparty conference participants also denounced the imprisonment of Khan and his wife, Bushra Imran, and demanded their immediate release.

The declaration agreed at the gathering also accused the government of “fascism and political victimization” and rejected the outcome of the 2024 elections as fraudulent.

It also called for repealing the 26th Amendment, which curtailed judicial autonomy by expanding parliamentary oversight of appointments, saying it had undermined judicial independence in Pakistan, and expressed solidarity with six

Islamabad High Court judges who had spoken out against institutional interference.

Tarar, however, dismissed the opposition’s assertions, saying the participants of the conference “had neither arguments nor facts.”

“Whenever a foreign visit to Pakistan is about to begin, especially by a foreign head of state, such actions are taken to sabotage it and damage the country’s economy,” he added, noting that the conference came just ahead of the Iranian president’s visit to Pakistan on Saturday.