Breaking barriers: How desert women from Pakistan’s Tharparkar defied odds to become active voters

In this file photo, taken on March 11, 2014, Pakistani villagers walk alongside the road in Mithi, the capital of Tharparkar district, some 300 kilometres from Karachi. (AFP/File)
Short Url
Updated 07 February 2024
Follow

Breaking barriers: How desert women from Pakistan’s Tharparkar defied odds to become active voters

  • Registered women voter turnout in 2018 went as high as 72.8 percent in Tharparkar, though it stood at 7.8 percent in places like Shangla
  • Krishna Kumari Kohli, a female senator from the desert region, hopes to witness increased women voter turnout on Feb. 8

THARPARKAR/KARACHI: It took a national tragedy for Hanju Kolhi, a 70-year-old Hindu woman from a small settlement near Islamkot in Tharparkar district, to start voting.
Kolhi participated in her first national election in 2008 after never casting a ballot before. The shift in her attitude was prompted by the assassination of former prime minister Benazir Bhutto in a gun-and-bomb attack while on the campaign trail in December 2007.
In subsequent years, Tharparkar’s desert region in the southern Sindh province witnessed a remarkable surge in women’s electoral participation, defying national trends. According to data analysis by the Free and Fair Election Network (FAFEN), turnout rates for women voters in the area soared in 2018 to an unprecedented 72.8 percent in NA-221 and 71.4 percent in NA-222.
Contrast this with the starkly different situation in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa’s NA-10 Shangla and NA-48 North Waziristan. In these areas, women’s presence at polling stations was rare, and conservative cultural norms combined with logistical hurdles kept turnout abysmally low, with figures languishing at 7.8 percent and 8.2 percent, respectively.
Tharparkar also led with the highest women voter turnout in the 2018 general election for provincial assembly seats. Four out of the top five constituencies nationwide having the highest number of women voters were situated in Tharparkar — the first, second, third and fifth constituencies.
“In the elections following Benazir Bhutto’s assassination, I began to cast my vote,” Kolhi told Arab News. “It was a response to my conscience, as Benazir sacrificed her life for us. In return, I felt it was my duty to vote for her. Voting for her is a matter of life and death for me.”
Speaking to Arab News, Ali Akbar Rahimoo, executive director of a Tharparkar-based social welfare organization, Aware, acknowledged the people of the region had exhibited political awareness by voting in recent electoral contests in large numbers.
However, he added that women were impeded from participating in the democratic process in the past by other factors as well, such as the absence of Computerized National Identity Cards (CNIC), which they later secured for financial reasons.
“For availing the Benazir Income Support Program (BISP), a large number of women obtained national identity cards, thereby gaining access to the voting rolls,” he said.
Rahimoo informed the National Database Registration Authority (NADRA), which issues CNICs to citizens, also became more accessible to the residents of the area, ensuring greater mobility among the populace in the arid region surrounded by a sprawling desert.
“While these cards have undoubtedly played a significant role, other factors have also influenced female voter turnout,” he said. “There was no drought in Tharparkar, and as such, no seasonal migration during the 2018 election, meaning that people remained in their constituencies and were able to vote.”
In the 2024 elections, Mehar-un-Nisa, an independent candidate backed by former Prime Minister Imran Khan’s Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) party, is vying for NA-215 (previously NA-221) from Tharparkar. She stands as the sole female candidate in the district who is running for a general seat either for the national or provincial assembly seat.
“Tharparkar suffers from poverty where people lack basic facilities,” she told Arab News. “Among them, Hindu minority women are the most deprived. This is the major reason they are very active in casting votes in an attempt to secure basic facilities from elected representatives.”
However, she noted that national parties often neglected to nominate women to contest for general seats, despite benefiting from their vote. Nisa maintained that the PTI, on the other hand, had a commitment to gender equality that was evident from her own nomination for the National Assembly general seat.
Krishna Kumari Kohli, a Pakistan Peoples Party (PPP) senator who holds the distinction of being the sole female parliamentarian in any legislative house to represent Tharparkar, said this was due to the lack of applications received by political parties from women candidates.
“In the past, Tharparkar saw limited participation of women in active politics,” she said. “However, the landscape is evolving, with the PPP leading by example through my election as the first senator from the district. It won’t be long before we witness multiple Tharparkar women representatives in legislative houses.”
The senator attributed the growing number of women voters to the expanding road network, increased access to education and heightened political awareness. Due to these factors, she added, the region was likely to witness an increased turnout of women voters in Tharparkar in the February 8 elections.
Nadia Naqi, a Karachi-based analyst, said the high turnout of women casting their ballots in Tharparkar primarily owed to its “open society.”
“When you go to rural areas in Sindh, you don’t see women who are always behind closed doors,” she said, adding that though women in some areas observed the veil, one could see many of them working in the fields.

Mentioning Shangla in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, she observed it was a society where women were not allowed to participate in public life.
“They are behind closed doors; there’s a totally different culture,” she said, noting there were cases when male candidates from different parties decided to prevent women from casting their votes. Naqi urged that women’s turnout should be increased across the country.
According to FAFEN officials, civil society groups have established effective coordination mechanisms with government departments, particularly the Election Commission of Pakistan (ECP) and NADRA, to mobilize women for voter registration.
These efforts, Rukhsana Shama of FAFEN told Arab News, included identification of cultural barriers to women’s registration and deploying mobile registration vehicles to underserved areas.
The coordination between the ECP and NADRA, she said, had increased the number of women voters from 2018 to 2024.
“This increase has been unprecedented because this is the first time that the ratio of women being registered as voters has been more than the men,” she said.
The FAFEN official informed that the registration deficit had decreased to 9.9 million from 12.7 million, which existed earlier.
With increased awareness, women residents of Tharparkar, like the 57-year-old Sangeeta Goel, plan to vote in the next elections.
“Women should cast their votes and elect rulers who care about them and resolve their issues,” she said.

 


‘Voice for the Voiceless’: Islamabad Police signs MoU to set up welfare service for stray animals

Updated 6 sec ago
Follow

‘Voice for the Voiceless’: Islamabad Police signs MoU to set up welfare service for stray animals

  • Police Animal Welfare Services will ensure treatment and rehabilitation of abandoned, injured and sick animals
  • The project will also include a shelter home, pet café and a hotel to help the residents of the city who plan to travel

ISLAMABAD: In a unique development for Pakistan, Islamabad Capital Territory (ICT) Police on Monday announced the signing of a memorandum of understanding (MoU) with an animal rescue organization to establish Police Animal Welfare Services (PAWS) aimed at ensuring the timely treatment and rehabilitation of abandoned, injured and sick animals.

The development follows the decision taken by Inspector General of Police Syed Ali Nasir Rizvi to start an initiative called the Voice for the Voiceless to help lost and stray animals. Islamabad has faced issues with stray dogs and cats, and there has been controversy surrounding the methods used to manage them, particularly the practice of culling by the Capital Development Authority (CDA).

Residents of the city also spot wildlife such as wild boars, leopards and monkeys occasionally due to their proximity with Margalla Hills, which boast thick vegetation and a diverse ecosystem.

The ICT Police mentioned the MoU signing with the JFK Animal Rescue and Shelter Organization in its statement to develop its capacity to help these creatures.

“The project includes establishment of a shelter home, a pet cafe, and a pet hotel for these animals, where citizens who travel or go on long journeys can avail these facilities for their pet where the best care of these animals will be ensured through professional caretakers,” the statement said.

“Moreover, this center will be built on most modern lines and international standards,” it continued. “Under PAWS, a K-9 mission will also be organized for the K-9 unit dogs of Islamabad Police, where, after retirement, these dogs will be handed over to citizens for complete care. Further assistance will be sought from other animal welfare organizations as needed.”

Rizvi said on the occasion that the initiative would echo the message of love and care for animals, as they were important to the environment, nature and human life.

He also noted that animals retiring after serving a force should not be put down, adding their complete care should be ensured.

Police forces around the world often engage in social responsibility ventures, though the nature and extent of these activities can vary widely depending on the country, local policies and community needs.


Pakistani politicians acknowledge Dubai properties revealed in data leak, say all assets duly declared

Updated 16 min 27 sec ago
Follow

Pakistani politicians acknowledge Dubai properties revealed in data leak, say all assets duly declared

  • Dubai Unlocked investigative project has revealed Pakistanis own residential properties worth $11 billion in Dubai 
  • UAE working in recent years to tighten legislation, increase cooperation with foreign law enforcement on extradition

ISLAMABAD: Top Pakistani politicians have dismissed a new leak of records that has revealed residential properties worth around $11 billion owned by the country’s political, military and business elite in Dubai, saying all mentioned assets had been legally declared.

Dubai Unlocked, an investigative project involving more than 70 media outlets around the globe, has revealed the ownership of properties in the Emirate of prominent global figures, including alleged money launderers and drug lords, political figures accused of corruption and their associates, and businessmen sanctioned for financing terrorism, among others.

The data spans 2020 and 2022 and only includes residential properties.

Pakistanis listed in leaks include President Asif Ali Zardari’s three children, former Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif’s son Hussain Nawaz Sharif, Interior Minister Mohsin Naqvi’s wife, Sindh provincial minister Sharjeel Memon and family members, Senator Faisal Vawda, Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf lawmaker Sher Afzal Marwat, and half a dozen lawmakers from the Sindh and Balochistan assemblies.

The Pakistani list also features the late Gen (retired) Pervez Musharraf, former prime minister Shaukat Aziz, former army chief Qamar Javed Bajwa’s son, and more than a dozen retired army generals as well as a police chief, an ambassador and a scientist, all of whom owned properties either directly or through their spouses and children.

Pakistani politicians and others were last named in the 2016 Panama Papers, leaked documents that showed how the rich exploit secretive offshore tax regimes.

“What is the new thing here,” Defense Minister Khawaja Muhammad Asif said on X, dismissing the leaks and saying all those named in the data were already known to have properties abroad.

Explaining his position on the issue, Pakistan’s interior minister Mohsin Naqvi said the Dubai property bought in his wife’s name in 2017 was fully declared and listed in tax returns.

“It was also declared in returns submitted to the Election Commission as caretaker CM [chief minister] of Punjab,” he said in an X post. “The property was sold a year ago, and a new property was purchased recently with the proceeds.”

Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) lawmaker and ex-PM Imran Khan aide, Sher Afzal Marwat, admitted he owned an apartment in Dubai, but had declared it with authorities in Pakistan, including the Federal Board of Revenue and the Election Commission of Pakistan.

“It can be confirmed with both the FBR and as well as ECP,” he said.

President Zardari’s Pakistan Peoples Party also said the properties of its leaders in Dubai had been duly declared in tax returns.

The property records at the heart of the Dubai Unlocked project come from multiple data leaks, mostly from the Dubai Land Department, as well as publicly owned utility companies. Taken together, the data provides a detailed overview of hundreds of thousands of properties in Dubai and information about their ownership or usage.

The data was obtained by the Center for Advanced Defense Studies (C4ADS), a non-profit organization based in Washington that researches international crime and conflict. It was then shared with Norwegian financial outlet E24 and the Organized Crime and Corruption Reporting Project (OCCRP), which coordinated an investigative project with dozens of media outlets from around the world.

The UAE was dealt a major reputational blow in March 2022 when it was flagged by global watchdog, the Financial Action Task Force (FATF), for “deficiencies” in its systems to combat money laundering and terror financing.

The move, which threatened to tarnish Dubai’s reputation as a premier center of finance, sparked a concerted effort by UAE authorities to tighten legislation and increase cooperation with foreign law enforcement on extradition.

 


US pledges increasing communication on terrorism, technical assistance for Pakistan’s border security

Updated 43 min 13 sec ago
Follow

US pledges increasing communication on terrorism, technical assistance for Pakistan’s border security

  • The State Department says the US agreed to help Pakistan with investigations related to IED attacks
  • It refuses to answer question about a recent drone attack in Pakistan that killed at least four villagers

ISLAMABAD: The United States said on Monday it had promised to provide technical assistance to Pakistan along its western border to deal with the threat of militant violence in the recent round of Counterterrorism Dialogue between the two countries held earlier this month.

The dialogue was initiated after the United States moved against the Taliban administration in Afghanistan after the September 11, 2001, attacks, aiming to provide a bilateral forum to both countries to address mutual concerns over militant violence.

The most recent phase of the dialogue took place on May 10 where Pakistan’s additional foreign secretary for the United Nations Syed Haider Shah co-chaired the meeting with US State Department Coordinator for Counterterrorism Elizabeth Richards.

“We confirmed with Pakistan today our bilateral intention to increase our capacity to meet emerging threats, specifically to increase communication on terrorism – specifically terrorism trends and movements of concern – in a way that is not just actionable within Pakistan but also an area that is actionable between our two countries,” State Department’s Principal Deputy Spokesperson Vedant Patel said during a media briefing.

“We also agreed about preventing and deterring terrorist groups and the work that can be done in that place, such as counter-IED [improvised explosive device] investigations, technical assistance at Pakistan’s western border, and other issues.”

The latest round of the Counterterrorism Dialogue was held against the backdrop of a surge in militant attacks in Pakistan by a proscribed network, Tehreek-e-Taliban Pakistan (TTP), whose leadership is reportedly based in neighboring Afghanistan.

Officials in Islamabad have frequently complained in recent months the Afghan interim administration in Kabul is not doing enough to clamp down on TTP militants and prevent them from launching attacks on Pakistani security forces and civilians.

The US withdrawal from Afghanistan was contingent upon several guarantees from the Taliban, one of which was that the Taliban would not allow any group or individual to use Afghan soil to threaten the security of the United States and its allies.

The agreement was signed in February 2020 in Doha, Qatar, and included commitments by the Taliban to sever ties with militant organizations like Al Qaeda.

The State Department official was also asked about a drone attack in South Waziristan in Pakistan’s Khyber Pakhtunkhwa province this week that killed at least four villagers. However, he did not answer the question.

“I don’t have anything for you on that,” he said. “I’d refer you to my colleagues at the Pentagon.”


Army major killed in gunfight with militants in Pakistan’s southwest

Updated 15 May 2024
Follow

Army major killed in gunfight with militants in Pakistan’s southwest

  • The intelligence-based operation was conducted in Zhob district of Pakistan’s restive Balochistan province
  • Balochistan is the site of a low-level insurgency by separatists who have recently carried out multiple attacks

ISLAMABAD: An army major and three militants were killed in a gunfight in Pakistan’s southwestern Balochistan province, the Pakistani military said on Tuesday.

The exchange of fire occurred during an intelligence-based operation in Sambaza area of Balochistan’s Zhob district, according to the Inter-Services Public Relations (ISPR), the military’s media wing.

Security forces effectively engaged the militants and killed three of them, seizing weapons, ammunition and explosives from the scene.

“During the intense exchange of fire, leading his troops from the front, Major Babar Khan (age: 33 years, resident of District Mianwali) having fought gallantly, paid the ultimate sacrifice and embraced Shahadat,” the ISPR said in a statement.

“Sanitization operation is being conducted to eliminate any other terrorist present in the area.”

Balochistan, which borders Afghanistan, is the site of a low-level insurgency by separatists, who have recently carried out a number of attacks in the region.

In one of the major attacks, gunmen last month killed nine people, who hailed from the eastern Punjab province, after abducting them from a bus on a highway near the Noshki district. The outlawed Balochistan Liberation Army (BLA) group claimed responsibility for the attack.

Although the government says it has quelled militancy, violence by various groups has persisted in the region.


Islamabad rejects ‘unhealthy’ remarks by Indian politicians about Pakistan’s nuclear capability, Kashmir

Updated 14 May 2024
Follow

Islamabad rejects ‘unhealthy’ remarks by Indian politicians about Pakistan’s nuclear capability, Kashmir

  • Pakistan has been key topic of Indian election speeches by PM Narendra Modi, top leaders of his ruling BJP party
  • Foreign Office urges Indian politicians to stop dragging Pakistan into their domestic politics for ‘electoral gains’

ISLAMABAD: Pakistan’s foreign office on Tuesday rejected “baseless” and “unhealthy” remarks by Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi and other members of his cabinet regarding Pakistan’s nuclear program, Kashmir dispute and other regional issues, which came during campaigning for ongoing elections in India.

Pakistan has been a key topic of speeches by Indian leaders during campaign rallies, with Modi and top leaders from his ruling Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) making strong statements about their South Asian neighbor.

At an election rally in Bihar this week, Modi indirectly referred to National Conference leader Farooq Abdullah’s remarks about Pakistan’s nuclear capabilities and said he would make Pakistan “wear bangles.”

Noting the “alarming” surge in anti-Pakistan rhetoric, Pakistan’s Foreign Office said it rejected the “irresponsible statements” by Indian leaders about the Jammu and Kashmir dispute, counter-terrorism efforts, bilateral relations and Pakistan’s nuclear capabilities.

“Regrettably, these statements reflect an unhealthy and entrenched obsession with Pakistan and reveal a deliberate intent to exploit hyper-nationalism for electoral gains. These also signify a desperate attempt to deflect attention from mounting domestic and international criticism,” Mumtaz Zahra Baloch, a Pakistani foreign office spokesperson, said in a statement.

“The bravado and jingoism exhibited by Indian leaders expose a reckless and extremist mindset. This mindset calls into question India’s capacity to be a responsible steward of its strategic capability. On the other hand, the purpose of Pakistan’s strategic capability is to safeguard its sovereignty and defend its territorial integrity.”

Baloch noted that Pakistan had clearly demonstrated its resolve to defend itself in the past and would not “hesitate to do so in the future should the Indian side choose to embark on a misadventure.”

About Indian Union Home Minister Amit Shah’s claim that Azad Kashmir was part of India, she said Jammu and Kashmir was an internationally-recognized disputed territory and the relevant UN Security Council resolutions clearly mandated a plebiscite in the territory for its final determination.

“No amount of inflated Indian statements can change this reality,” Baloch said. “India should, therefore, focus on implementing these resolutions instead of indulging in fantasies of grandeur.”

The Himalayan territory of Kashmir has been divided between India and Pakistan since their independence from Britain in 1947, with both countries ruling part of the territory but claiming it in full.

The western portion of the larger Kashmir region is administered by Pakistan as a nominally self-governing entity, while India rules the southern portion as a union territory.

Baloch urged Indian politicians to stop dragging Pakistan into their domestic politics for “electoral gains” and to handle sensitive strategic matters with “utmost caution.”

“We call upon the international community to take note of Indian leadership’s belligerent rhetoric, which poses a grave threat to regional peace and stability,” she said.

“The vision of peace, progress, and prosperity in South Asia can only be realized through the peaceful resolution of all outstanding disputes, including Jammu and Kashmir, and a shift from confrontation to cooperation.”