Israel’s Western allies slam Israeli minister’s remark that Gaza starvation may be justified

Israeli Finance Minister Bezalel Smotrich, a key partner in Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s governing coalition, supports the reoccupation of Gaza. (AP)
Israeli Finance Minister Bezalel Smotrich, a key partner in Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s governing coalition, supports the reoccupation of Gaza. (AP)
Short Url
Updated 09 August 2024
Follow

Israel’s Western allies slam Israeli minister’s remark that Gaza starvation may be justified

Israeli Finance Minister Bezalel Smotrich supports the reoccupation of Gaza. (AP)
  • EU on Wednesday condemned Smotrich’s remarks, noting that the “deliberate starvation of civilians is a war crime”
  • David Lammy, Britain’s new foreign secretary, said “there can be no justification for Minister Smotrich’s remarks”

JERUSALEM: Israel’s Western allies have condemned remarks by the country’s far-right finance minister who suggested that the starvation of Gaza’s population of more than 2 million Palestinians “might be just and moral” until hostages captured in Hamas’ Oct. 7 attack on southern Israel are returned home.
Finance Minister Bezalel Smotrich said in a speech on Monday that Israel had no choice but to send humanitarian aid into Gaza.
“It’s not possible in today’s global reality to manage a war — no one will allow us to starve 2 million people, even though that might be just and moral until they return the hostages,” he said at a conference in support of Jewish settlements.
Smotrich, a key partner in Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s governing coalition, supports the reoccupation of Gaza, the rebuilding of Jewish settlements that were removed in 2005, and what he describes as the voluntary migration of large numbers of Palestinians out of the territory.
The European Union on Wednesday condemned his remarks, noting that the “deliberate starvation of civilians is a war crime.”
EU foreign policy chief Josep Borrell called the remarks “beyond ignominious,” saying “it demonstrates, once again, his contempt for international law and for basic principles of humanity.”
David Lammy, Britain’s new foreign secretary, said “there can be no justification for Minister Smotrich’s remarks.”
“We expect the wider Israeli government to retract and condemn them,” he wrote on the social media platform X.
Germany’s ambassador to Israel, Steffen Siebert, called the remarks “unacceptable and appalling.”
“It is a principle of international law and of humanity to protect civilians in a war and to give them access to water and food,” he wrote on X.
Egypt’s foreign ministry on Thursday also condemned Smotrich’s remarks, describing them as “shameful statements unacceptable in form and substance” and a violation of international humanitarian law. Such “irresponsible statements” create incitement against Palestinians in the Gaza Strip, the ministry added.
The ongoing war sparked by Hamas’ attack has plunged Gaza into a humanitarian catastrophe. The vast majority of its population has been displaced within the blockaded territory, often multiple times, and hundreds of thousands are packed into squalid tent camps. The leading international authority on the severity of hunger crises, the Integrated Food Security Phase Classification, said in June that Gaza was at “high risk” of famine.
Aid organizations say efforts to deliver food and other assistance have been hindered by Israeli restrictions, ongoing fighting and the breakdown of law and order. Israel says it allows unlimited humanitarian aid to enter and blames UN agencies for failing to promptly deliver it.
Hamas-led militants killed about 1,200 people in the surprise attack into Israel that triggered the war and took around 250 hostages. Some 110 hostages are still being held in Gaza, though Israel believes that about a third of them are dead. Most of the rest were released during a weeklong November ceasefire.
Israel’s ongoing offensive has killed nearly 40,000 Palestinians, according to Gaza’s Health Ministry, and has caused widespread devastation.

The Yazidi nightmare
Ten years after the genocide, their torment continues

Enter


keywords

Israeli minister Ben Gvir, settlers storm Al-Aqsa compound

Israeli minister Ben Gvir, settlers storm Al-Aqsa compound
Updated 55 sec ago
Follow

Israeli minister Ben Gvir, settlers storm Al-Aqsa compound

Israeli minister Ben Gvir, settlers storm Al-Aqsa compound

JERUSALEM: Far-right Israeli National Security Minister Itamar Ben Gvir on Monday entered the Al-Aqsa Mosque compound — known to Jews as the Temple Mount — during controversial “Jerusalem Day” celebrations that mark Israel’s 1967 capture of East Jerusalem.

His visit came as more than 900 extremist Jewish settlers, accompanied by Israeli police, stormed the courtyards of the holy site, according to the Jerusalem Islamic Waqf Department. The group included Knesset members and rabbis who performed what the Waqf described as “provocative Talmudic rituals” in various areas of the compound.

In one instance, a settler raised an Israeli flag and danced in the eastern section of Al-Aqsa, an act seen as a violation of the longstanding status quo governing the site, which is sacred to both Muslims and Jews.

The Waqf also reported that settlers attempted to bring Torah scrolls through the Mughrabi Gate, while hundreds more gathered in Al-Buraq Square and at Qattanin Gate, where they held religious dances and rituals.

Extremist Knesset member Moshe Feiglin was reportedly planning to enter the site later in the day after awarding a medal to a retired Israeli soldier who took part in the 1967 occupation of Jerusalem.

In anticipation of unrest, Israeli police imposed tight restrictions across the Old City, erecting iron barriers at Damascus Gate and other entry points, heavily limiting Palestinian access.

The annual “Flag March,” expected to pass through densely populated Palestinian areas such as Damascus Gate and Al-Wad Street, has raised tensions, with settler incursions and harassment of Muslim worshippers reportedly increasing in recent days.


Iran rejects temporary halt on uranium enrichment to secure US nuclear deal

Iran rejects temporary halt on uranium enrichment to secure US nuclear deal
Updated 36 min 19 sec ago
Follow

Iran rejects temporary halt on uranium enrichment to secure US nuclear deal

Iran rejects temporary halt on uranium enrichment to secure US nuclear deal

DUBAI: Iran will not consider temporarily suspending uranium enrichment to secure a nuclear deal with the US, a foreign ministry spokesperson said on Monday, adding that no date had yet been set for a sixth round of talks with Washington.
The negotiations between Washington and Tehran aim to resolve a decades-long dispute over Iran’s nuclear ambitions, and both sides have taken a tough stance in public over the issue of Iran’s uranium enrichment.
Asked about reports that Iran could freeze enrichment for three years to reach an agreement, spokesperson Esmail Baghaei told a press conference: “Iran will never accept that.”
Baghaei also ruled out the possibility of an interim nuclear deal with the US, dismissing media reports that a provisional agreement was being considered as a temporary step toward a final deal.
President Donald Trump said on Sunday that US negotiators had “very good” talks with an Iranian delegation over the weekend.
Iran is waiting for further details from mediator Oman regarding the timing of the next round of talks, Baghaei said.
“If there is goodwill from the American side, we are also optimistic, but if talks are aimed at curbing Iran’s rights then talks will get nowhere,” he added.
The stakes are high for both sides.
Trump wants to curtail Tehran’s potential to produce a nuclear weapon that could trigger a regional nuclear arms race and perhaps threaten Israel. Iran, for its part, maintains its nuclear program is exclusively for civilian purposes and wants to be rid of devastating sanctions on its oil-based economy.


Head of controversial US-backed Gaza aid group resigns

Head of controversial US-backed Gaza aid group resigns
Updated 26 May 2025
Follow

Head of controversial US-backed Gaza aid group resigns

Head of controversial US-backed Gaza aid group resigns
  • Jake Wood says he accepted the role as head of Gaza Humanitarian Foundation "to help alleviate the suffering" in Gaza
  • But he is stepping down because “it had become clear that implementing the organization’s plan was not possible”

WASHINGTON: The head of a controversial US-backed group preparing to move aid into the Gaza Strip announced his abrupt resignation Sunday, adding fresh uncertainty over the effort’s future.
In a statement by the Gaza Humanitarian Foundation (GHF), executive director Jake Wood explained that he felt compelled to leave after determining the organization could not fulfil its mission in a way that adhered to “humanitarian principles.”
The foundation, which has been based in Geneva since February, has vowed to distribute some 300 million meals in its first 90 days of operation.
But the United Nations and traditional aid agencies have already said they will not cooperate with the group, amid accusations it is working with Israel.
The GHF has emerged as international pressure mounts on Israel over the conditions in Gaza, where it has pursued a military onslaught in response to the October 7, 2023 attacks by Hamas.
A more than two-month total blockade on the territory only began to ease in recent days, as agencies warned of growing starvation risks.
“Two months ago, I was approached about leading GHF’s efforts because of my experience in humanitarian operations” Wood said.
“Like many others around the world, I was horrified and heartbroken at the hunger crisis in Gaza and, as a humanitarian leader, I was compelled to do whatever I could to help alleviate the suffering.”
Wood stressed that he was “proud of the work I oversaw, including developing a pragmatic plan that could feed hungry people, address security concerns about diversion, and complement the work of longstanding NGOs in Gaza.”
But, he said, it had become “clear that it is not possible to implement this plan while also strictly adhering to the humanitarian principles of humanity, neutrality, impartiality, and independence, which I will not abandon.”
Gaza’s health ministry said Sunday that at least 3,785 people had been killed in the territory since a ceasefire collapsed on March 18, taking the war’s overall toll to 53,939, mostly civilians.
Hamas’s October 2023 attack on Israel that triggered the war resulted in the deaths of 1,218 people, mostly civilians, according to an AFP tally based on official figures.
Militants also took 251 hostages, 57 of whom remain in Gaza including 34 the Israeli military says are dead.
Wood called on Israel “to significantly expand the provision of aid into Gaza through all mechanisms” while also urging “all stakeholders to continue to explore innovative new methods for the delivery of aid, without delay, diversion, or discrimination.”

 


Israeli strikes kill 46 in Gaza, including 31 in a school-turned shelter, medics say

Israeli strikes kill 46 in Gaza, including 31 in a school-turned shelter, medics say
Updated 26 May 2025
Follow

Israeli strikes kill 46 in Gaza, including 31 in a school-turned shelter, medics say

Israeli strikes kill 46 in Gaza, including 31 in a school-turned shelter, medics say
  • Medics said the dozens of casualties in the strike on the school, in the Daraj neighbourhood of Gaza City, included women and children

GAZA CITY: Israeli strikes killed at least 46 people in the Gaza Strip on Monday, including 31 in a school-turned-shelter that was struck as people slept, igniting their belongings, according to local health officials. 
Israel renewed its offensive in March after ending a ceasefire with Hamas. It has vowed to seize control of Gaza and keep fighting until Hamas is destroyed or disarmed, and until it returns the remaining 58 hostages, a third of them believed to be alive, from the Oct. 7, 2023, attack that ignited the war.
Israel began allowing a trickle of humanitarian aid into Gaza last week after blocking all food, medicine, fuel or other goods from entering for 2 1/2 months. Aid groups have warned of famine and say the aid that has come in is nowhere near enough to meeting mounting needs.
A new aid system supported by Israel and the United States but rejected by UN agencies and aid groups is expected to begin operations as soon as Monday, despite the resignation of the American leading the effort, who said it would not be able to operate independently.
Israel says it plans to seize full control of Gaza and facilitate what it describes as the voluntary migration of its over 2 million population, a plan rejected by Palestinians and much of the international community.
Israel's military campaign has destroyed vast areas of Gaza and internally displaced some 90% of its population. Many have fled multiple times.
 

Rescuers recover charred remains
The strike on the school in the Daraj neighborhood of Gaza City also wounded more than 55 people, said Fahmy Awad, head of the ministry’s emergency service. He said a father and his five children were among the dead.
He said the school was hit three times while people slept, setting their belongings ablaze. Footage circulating online showed rescuers struggling to extinguish fires and recovering charred remains.
The military said it targeted a militant command and control center inside the school that Hamas and Islamic Jihad used to gather intelligence for attacks. Israel blames civilian deaths on Hamas because it operates in residential areas.
A separate strike on a home killed 15 members of the same family, including five women and two children, according to Shifa Hospital in Gaza City, which received the bodies.

Plans to control aid hit another obstacle
Israel plans to roll out a new aid distribution system run by a group known as the Gaza Humanitarian Foundation, made up of former humanitarian, government and military officials, that would set up distribution points guarded by private security firms. Israel accuses Hamas of siphoning off assistance, without providing evidence.
The foundation said in a statement that it would begin delivering aid Monday and would reach a million Palestinians — around half of Gaza's population — by the end of the week.
UN agencies and major aid groups have refused to cooperate with the planned U.S.-backed system, saying it would force even more displacement, fail to meet local needs and violate humanitarian principles that prohibit a warring party from controlling humanitarian assistance. They also say there is no evidence of systematic diversion of aid by militants.
Jake Wood, the American heading the foundation, unexpectedly resigned Sunday, saying it had become clear that the foundation would not be allowed to operate independently. It’s not clear who is funding the group.
Hamas-led militants killed some 1,200 people, mostly civilians, and abducted 251 people in the 2023 attack. More than half the hostages have been returned in ceasefire agreements or other deals, eight have been rescued, and Israeli forces have recovered the remains of dozens more.
The offensive has destroyed vast areas of Gaza, rendering entire neighborhoods uninhabitable. Hundreds of thousands of people have been forced to shelter in schools and squalid tent camps for well over a year.
Israel’s retaliatory offensive has killed around 54,000 Palestinians, according to the Gaza Health Ministry. It says more than half the dead are women and children but does not distinguish between civilians and combatants in its count.


Israel leader meets visiting US homeland security secretary: PM’s office

Israel leader meets visiting US homeland security secretary: PM’s office
Updated 26 May 2025
Follow

Israel leader meets visiting US homeland security secretary: PM’s office

Israel leader meets visiting US homeland security secretary: PM’s office
  • The visit comes as Israel ramps up its offensive in the Gaza Strip

JERUSALEM: Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu met with visiting US Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem in Jerusalem on Sunday, his office said.
US and Israeli media reported that Trump had sent Noem to Jerusalem following the killing of two Israeli embassy staffers in Washington last week.
Noem was accompanied at her meeting with Netanyahu by US Ambassador Mike Huckabee, Netanyahu’s office said in a brief statement Sunday night.
The office added that during the meeting Noem “expressed her unreserved support for the prime minister and the State of Israel.”
The visit comes as Israel ramps up its offensive in the Gaza Strip in what it says is a renewed effort to destroy Hamas.
Earlier in the evening, Noem and Huckabee had visited the city’s Western Wall, where early celebrations for Monday’s “Jerusalem Day” holiday were taking place.
The holiday commemorates what Israel considers Jerusalem’s reunification under its authority after the city’s eastern sector was captured by its forces in the 1967 Arab-Israeli war.